Cor Vasa 2013, 55(5):e403-e410 | DOI: 10.1016/j.crvasa.2013.06.001
Optimization of pacing intervals in cardiac resynchronization therapy
- Kardiologické oddělení, Komplexní kardiovaskulární centrum, Lékařská fakulta v Plzni, Univerzita Karlova v Praze a Fakultní nemocnice Plzeň, Plzeň, Česká republika
In patients with heart failure, left ventricular systolic dysfunction and prolonged QRS complex, cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) is a treatment method aimed at restoration of myocardial depolarization synchronicity. However, the extent of clinical and echocardiographic improvement depends on anatomical relations in individual patients, on structural changes in the heart, on intrinsic electrical activation, and on the position of pacing leads. Many parameters of CRT devices may be changed in order to tailor the function of CRT to the needs of a particular patient; the most important among them is AV and VV interval. The largest trials studying CRT used various methods for optimization of these intervals but unequivocal proof of the benefit brought by optimization is still lacking. Many methods were evaluated, most frequently based on echocardiography and intracardiac electrogram interval measurement. However, drawbacks in statistics make the studies of limited value for establishing a reference method or guidance for daily practice. Echocardiography has inherent variability of results and is highly operator dependent. Optimization based on intracardiac electrogram intervals has not proved yet to be of clear benefit above arbitrary AV interval. The most promising method is finger plethysmography. Measured data are highly reproducible and operator-independent. A randomized multicenter double-blind study using finger plethysmography is needed to prove the value of this method and of CRT optimization in general. The measurement of information content in any data suitable for CRT optimization, analysis of reproducibility and general usage of confidence intervals may show other methods appropriate for it, too. The cooperation with a statistician is oftentimes a necessity.
Keywords: Cardiac resynchronization therapy; Finger plethysmography; Hemodynamics of pacing; Optimization of pacing intervals; Statistical data analysis
Received: January 26, 2013; Accepted: June 8, 2013; Published: October 1, 2013 Show citation
References
- M.R. Bristow, L.A. Saxon, J. Boehmer, et al., Cardiac-resynchronization therapy with or without an implantable defibrillator in advanced chronic heart failure, The New England Journal of Medicine 350 (2004) 2140-2150.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- A. Auricchio, A. Kramer, J.C. Spinelli, et al., Can the optimum dosage of resynchronization therapy be derived from the intracardiac electrogram? [abstract], Journal of the American College of Cardiology 39 (2002) 124A.
Go to original source...
- J.G. Cleland, J.C. Daubert, E. Erdmann, et al., The CARE-HF study (CArdiac REsynchronisation in Heart Failure study): rationale, design and end-points, European Journal of Heart Failure 3 (2001) 481-489.
Go to original source...
- J.G. Cleland, J.C. Daubert, E. Erdmann, et al., The effect of cardiac resynchronization on morbidity and mortality in heart failure, The New England Journal of Medicine 352 (2005) 1539-1549.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M. Brignole, D. Oddone, R. Maggi, et al., Resynchronization of the left ventricular contraction by tailored programming of right and left ventricular pacing, Europace 10 (2008) 489-495.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- K. Kurzidim, H. Reinke, J. Sperzel, et al., Invasive optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy: role of sequential biventricular and left ventricular pacing, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 28 (2005) 754-761.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M. Bocchiardo, D. Meyer zu Vilsendorf, C. Militello, et al., Resynchronization therapy optimization by intracardiac impedance, Europace 12 (2010) 1589-1595.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- P.H. Ritter, J.C. Dib, T. Lelievre, Quick determination of the optimal AV delay at rest in patients paced in DDD mode for complete AV block [abstract], European Journal of Cardiac Pacing and Electrophysiology 4 (1994) A163.
- J. Meluzin, M. Novak, J. Mullerova, et al., A fast and simple echocardiographic method of determination of the optimal atrioventricular delay in patients after biventricular stimulation, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 27 (2004) 58-64.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- J.S. Colocousis, L.L. Huntsman, P.W. Curreri, Estimation of stroke volume changes by ultrasonic doppler, Circulation 56 (1977) 914-917.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- R.G. Turcott, R.M. Witteles, P.J. Wang, et al., Measurement precision in the optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy, Circulation: Heart Failure 3 (2010) 395-404.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- B. Vidal, M. Sitges, A. Marigliano, et al., Optimizing the programation of cardiac resynchronization therapy devices in patients with heart failure and left bundle branch block, The American Journal of Cardiology 100 (2007) 1002-1006.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- E. Madriago, D.J. Sahn, S. Balaji, Optimization of myocardial strain imaging and speckle tracking for resynchronization after congenital heart surgery in children, Europace 12 (2010) 1341-1343.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- A. Deplagne, P. Bordachar, P. Reant, et al., Additional value of three-dimensional echocardiography in patients with cardiac resynchronization therapy, Archives of Cardiovascular Diseases 102 (2009) 497-508.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M.C. Porciani, C. Dondina, R. Macioce, et al., Echocardiographic examination of atrioventricular and interventricular delay optimization in cardiac resynchronization therapy, The American Journal of Cardiology 95 (2005) 1108-1110.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M.C. Porciani, C. Dondina, R. Macioce, et al., Temporal variation in optimal atrioventricular and interventricular delay during cardiac resynchronization therapy, Journal of Cardiac Failure 12 (2006) 715-719.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- J.M. Dizon, T.A. Quinn, S.E. Cabreriza, et al., Real-time stroke volume measurements for the optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy parameters, Europace 12 (2010) 1270-1274.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- E. Sciaraffia, H. Malmborg, S. Lonnerholm, et al., The use of impedance cardiography for optimizing the interventricular stimulation interval in cardiac resynchronization therapy - a comparison with left ventricular contractility, Journal of Interventional Cardiac Electrophysiology 25 (2009) 223-228.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- K.M. Heinroth, M. Elster, S. Nuding, et al., Impedance cardiography: a useful and reliable tool in optimization of cardiac resynchronization devices, Europace 9 (2007) 744-750.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M.U. Braun, A. Schnabel, T. Rauwolf, et al., Impedance cardiography as a noninvasive technique for atrioventricular interval optimization in cardiac resynchronization therapy, Journal of Interventional Cardiac Electrophysiology 13 (2005) 223-229.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Q. Zhang, J.W. Fung, Y.S. Chan, et al., The role of repeating optimization of atrioventricular interval during interim and long-term follow-up after cardiac resynchronization therapy, International Journal of Cardiology 124 (2008) 211-217.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- F.Z. Khan, M.S. Virdee, J. Hutchinson, et al., Cardiac resynchronization therapy optimization using noninvasive cardiac output measurement, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 34 (2011) 1527-1536.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- N. Reinsch, T. Konorza, D. Woydowski, et al., Iterative cardiac output measurement for optimizing cardiac resynchronization therapy: a randomized, blinded, crossover study, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 33 (2010) 1188-1194.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- D. Prochnau, T. Forberg, H. Kuhnert, et al., Optimization of the atrioventricular delay during cardiac resynchronization therapy using a device for non-invasive measurement of cardiac index at rest and during exercise, Europace 14 (2012) 249-253.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M. Stahlberg, M. Damgaard, P. Norsk, et al., Cardiac output response to changes of the atrioventricular delay in different body positions and during exercise in patients receiving cardiac resynchronization therapy, Europace 11 (2009) 1160-1167.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- I.E. van Geldorp, T. Delhaas, B. Hermans, et al., Comparison of a non-invasive arterial pulse contour technique and echo Doppler aorta velocity-time integral on stroke volume changes in optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy, Europace 13 (2011) 87-95.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Z.I. Whinnett, C. Briscoe, J.E. Davies, et al., The atrioventricular delay of cardiac resynchronization can be optimized hemodynamically during exercise and predicted from resting measurements, Heart Rhythm 5 (2008) 378-386.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- A. Hasan, W.T. Abraham, L. Quinn-Tate, et al., Optimization of cardiac resynchronization devices using acoustic cardiography: a comparison to echocardiography, Congestive Heart Failure 12 (Suppl. 1) (2006) 25-31.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- S. Toggweiler, M. Zuber, R. Kobza, et al., Improved response to cardiac resynchronization therapy through optimization of atrioventricular and interventricular delays using acoustic cardiography: a pilot study, Journal of Cardiac Failure 13 (2007) 637-642.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M. Zuber, S. Toggweiler, L. Quinn-Tate, et al., A comparison of acoustic cardiography and echocardiography for optimizing pacemaker settings in cardiac resynchronization therapy, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 31 (2008) 802-811.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M. Zuber, S. Toggweiler, M. Roos, et al., Comparison of different approaches for optimization of atrioventricular and interventricular delay in biventricular pacing, Europace 10 (2008) 367-373.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Y. Miki, T. Ishikawa, K. Matsushita, et al., Optimal programming of the atrioventricular delay using the phonocardiogram, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 32 (Suppl. 1) (2009) S81-S85.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- E. Donal, L. Giorgis, S. Cazeau, et al., Endocardial acceleration (sonR) vs. ultrasound-derived time intervals in recipients of cardiac resynchronization therapy systems, Europace 13 (2011) 402-408.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M. Bertini, M. Ziacchi, M. Biffi, et al., Interventricular delay interval optimization in cardiac resynchronization therapy guided by echocardiography versus guided by electrocardiographic QRS interval width, The American Journal of Cardiology 102 (2008) 1373-1377.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- D. Tamborero, L. Mont, M. Sitges, et al., Optimization of the interventricular delay in cardiac resynchronization therapy using the QRS width, The American Journal of Cardiology 104 (2009) 1407-1412.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- D. Tamborero, B. Vidal, J.M. Tolosana, et al., Electrocardiographic versus echocardiographic optimization of the interventricular pacing delay in patients undergoing cardiac resynchronization therapy, Journal of Cardiovascular Electrophysiology 22 (2011) 1129-1134.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- B. Vidal, D. Tamborero, L. Mont, et al., Electrocardiographic optimization of interventricular delay in cardiac resynchronization therapy: a simple method to optimize the device, Journal of Cardiovascular Electrophysiology 18 (2007) 1252-1257.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- B. Herweg, R. Ali, A. Ilerci, et al., Site-specific differences in latency intervals during biventricular pacing: impact on paced QRS morphology and echo-optimized V-V interval, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 33 (2010) 1382-1391.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M.C. Porciani, C.M. Rao, M. Mochi, et al., A real-time three-dimensional echocardiographic validation of an intracardiac electrogram-based method for optimizing cardiac resynchronization therapy, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 31 (2008) 56-63.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- R. Kamdar, E. Frain, F. Warburton, et al., A prospective comparison of echocardiography and device algorithms for atrioventricular and interventricular interval optimization in cardiac resynchronization therapy, Europace 12 (2010) 84-91.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- G. Golovchiner, P. Dorian, I. Mangat, et al., Electrogram-based optimal atrioventricular and interventricular delays of cardiac resynchronization change individually during exercise, The Canadian Journal of Cardiology 27 (2011) 351-357.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M.C. Porciani, I. Ricceri, P. Attana, et al., Discordant electrical and mechanical atrial delays affect intracavitary electrogram-based cardiac resynchronization therapy optimization, Europace 14 (2012) 593-598.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- C. Valzania, M.J. Eriksson, G. Boriani, F. Gadler, Cardiac resynchronization therapy during rest and exercise: comparison of two optimization methods, Europace 10 (2008) 1161-1169.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M.R. Gold, I. Niazi, M. Giudici, et al., A prospective comparison of AV delay programming methods for hemodynamic optimization during cardiac resynchronization therapy, Journal of Cardiovascular Electrophysiology 18 (2007) 490-496.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- H. Krum, B. Lemke, D. Birnie, et al., A novel algorithm for individualized cardiac resynchronization therapy: rationale and design of the adaptive cardiac resynchronization therapy trial, American Heart Journal 163 (2012) 747-752.e1.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- N.S. Sawhney, A.D. Waggoner, S. Garhwal, et al., Randomized prospective trial of atrioventricular delay programming for cardiac resynchronization therapy, Heart Rhythm 1 (2004) 562-567.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- K.M. Stein, K.A. Ellenbogen, M.R. Gold, et al., SmartDelay determined AV optimization: a comparison of AV delay methods used in cardiac resynchronization therapy (SMART-AV): rationale and design, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 33 (2010) 54-63.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- K.A. Ellenbogen, M.R. Gold, T.E. Meyer, et al., Primary results from the SmartDelay determined AV optimization: a comparison to other AV delay methods used in cardiac resynchronization therapy (SMART-AV) trial: a randomized trial comparing empirical, echocardiography-guided, and algorithmic atrioventricular delay programming in cardiac resynchronization therapy, Circulation 122 (2010) 2660-2668.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- W.T. Abraham, C.M. Yu, L. Calo, et al., Randomized clinical trial to assess the safety and efficacy of frequent optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy using the QuickOpt method (FREEDOM) trial results, Heart Rhythm Scientific Sessions. Denver, CO, 2010.
Go to original source...
- G. Boriani, C.P. Muller, K.H. Seidl, et al., Randomized comparison of simultaneous biventricular stimulation versus optimized interventricular delay in cardiac resynchronization therapy. The Resynchronization for the HemodYnamic Treatment for Heart Failure Management II implantable cardioverter defibrillator (RHYTHM II ICD) study, American Heart Journal 151 (2006) 1050-1058.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- G. Boriani, M. Biffi, C.P. Muller, et al., A prospective randomized evaluation of VV delay optimization in CRT-D recipients: echocardiographic observations from the RHYTHM II ICD study, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 32 (Suppl. 1) (2009) S120-S125.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- R.K. Rao, U.N. Kumar, J. Schafer, et al., Reduced ventricular volumes and improved systolic function with cardiac resynchronization therapy: a randomized trial comparing simultaneous biventricular pacing, sequential biventricular pacing, and left ventricular pacing, Circulation 115 (2007) 2136-2144.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- D.O. Martin, B. Lemke, D. Birnie, et al., Adaptive CRTSI. Investigation of a novel algorithm for synchronized left-ventricular pacing and ambulatory optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy: results of the adaptive CRT trial, Heart Rhythm 9 (2012) 1807-1814.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- J.H. Baker, 2nd, J. McKenzie, 3rd, S. Beau, et al., Acute evaluation of programmer-guided AV/PV and VV delay optimization comparing an IEGM method and echocardiogram for cardiac resynchronization therapy in heart failure patients and dual-chamber ICD implants, Journal of Cardiovascular Electrophysiology 18 (2007) 185-191.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- M. Anselmino, M. Antolini, C. Amellone, et al., Optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy: echocardiographic vs semiautomatic device algorithms, Congestive Heart Failure 15 (2009) 14-18.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- A.H. Jansen, F.A. Bracke, J.M. van Dantzig, et al., Correlation of echo-Doppler optimization of atrioventricular delay in cardiac resynchronization therapy with invasive hemodynamics in patients with heart failure secondary to ischemic or idiopathic dilated cardiomyopathy, The American Journal of Cardiology 97 (2006) 552-557.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- D.E. Thomas, Z.R. Yousef, A.G. Fraser, A critical comparison of echocardiographic measurements used for optimizing cardiac resynchronization therapy: stroke distance is best, European Journal of Heart Failure 11 (2009) 779-788.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Z.I. Whinnett, J.E. Davies, K. Willson, et al., Determination of optimal atrioventricular delay for cardiac resynchronization therapy using acute non-invasive blood pressure, Europace 8 (2006) 358-366.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- P.A. Pabari, K. Willson, B. Stegemann, et al., When is an optimization not an optimization? Evaluation of clinical implications of information content (signal-to-noise ratio) in optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy, and how to measure and maximize it, Heart Failure Reviews 16 (2011) 277-290.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Z.I. Whinnett, G. Nott, J.E. Davies, et al., Maximizing efficiency of alternation algorithms for hemodynamic optimization of the AV delay of cardiac resynchronization therapy, Pacing and Clinical Electrophysiology 34 (2011) 217-225.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- C.H. Manisty, A. Al-Hussaini, B. Unsworth, et al., The acute effects of changes to AV delay on BP and stroke volume: potential implications for design of pacemaker optimization protocols, Circulation: Arrhythmia and Electrophysiology 5 (2012) 122-130.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- Z.I. Whinnett, J.E. Davies, G. Nott, et al., Efficiency, reproducibility and agreement of five different hemodynamic measures for optimization of cardiac resynchronization therapy, International Journal of Cardiology 129 (2008) 216-226.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...
- C. Melzer, A.C. Borges, F. Knebel, et al., Echocardiographic AV-interval optimization in patients with reduced left ventricular function, Cardiovascular Ultrasound 2 (2004) 30.
Go to original source...
Go to PubMed...